Learning that a judge may overturn their historic decision to hold the chemical company Monsanto-Bayer accountable for manufacturing cancer-causing weedkillers, several jurors are demanding that their verdict in a case decided in August be upheld.
Gary Kitahata and Robert Howard are among the jurors who unanimously found that Monsanto was liable for $289 million in damages, to be paid to former school groundskeeper Dewayne Johnson, who was diagnosed with terminal cancer after spending years using Monsanto’s products at his job.
In two separate letters written in recent days, Kitahata and Howard appealed to California Superior Court Judge Suzanne Bolanos this week after she announced her consideration of a retrial and indicated she might overturn nearly all of the damages the jury awarded to Johnson.
Kitihata and the other jurors found that Monsanto owed $250 million to Johnson in punitive damages as well as $31 million for shortening his life expectancy. Bolanos said in a public hearing last Wednesday that she may overturn both sums, leaving Johnson with $8 million. The judge is expected to reach a decision by next Monday.
In a statement to Common Dreams, Katherine Paul, U.S. national director for the Organic Consumers Union, denounced the judge’s consideration of a severely reduced verdict for Monsanto’s benefit.
“It’s unfortunate that the court is willing to consider overturning the verdict of 12 jurors who carefully and thoughtfully made their decision based on factual evidence,” Paul said. “We hope the judge in this case will not be pressured by Monsanto-Bayer, but will instead respect the jury’s decision and rule in favor of public health, not corporate profits.”
“You may not have been convinced by the evidence, but we were,” Kitahata wrote to Bolanos in his letter. “I urge you to respect and honor our verdict and the six weeks of our lives that we dedicated to this trial.”
The possibility that the jury’s “unanimous verdict could be summarily overturned demeans our system of justice and shakes my confidence in that system,” wrote Howard in his own letter.
Glyphosate was classified by the World Health Organization as a “probably human carcinogen” in 2015, the same year Johnson as diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer and a year after a previous diagnosis of non-Hodgkins lymphoma.
Johnson’s case was just the first to go to trial out of more 4,000 lawsuits against the company, with plaintiffs across the country arguing Monsanto’s products contributed significantly to their cancer diagnoses.