What a world without prisons could look like | Deanna Van Buren

Deanna Van Buren designs restorative justice centers that, instead of taking the punitive approach used by a system focused on mass incarceration, treat crime as a breach of relationships and justice as a process where all stakeholders come together to repair that breach. With help and ideas from incarcerated men and women, Van Buren is creating dynamic spaces that provide safe venues for dialogue and reconciliation; employment and job training; and social services to help keep people from entering the justice system in the first place. "Imagine a world without prisons," Van Buren says. "And join me in creating all the things that we could build instead."

Check out more TED Talks:

The TED Talks channel features the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes (or less). Look for talks on Technology, Entertainment and Design — plus science, business, global issues, the arts and more.

Follow TED on Twitter:
Like TED on Facebook:

Subscribe to our channel:

75 Comments on What a world without prisons could look like | Deanna Van Buren

  1. So two wrongs make a right mixed with womenism. Yes the system is broken. But the system is not what made people commit crimes to begin with.

    • Beatness bruh. there are cases of sadists and psycopaths who commit crimes for fun. we have emotions and get angry, there are times where life is not fair. we do not have infinite resourses for all and we reward conpetancy.

    • Beatness There’s a large swath of psychopathic serial killers who we can’t rehabilitate. Yeah sure, I’d love to help the guy who Rob’s a gas station because he’s hooked on crack. Something tells me this woman might think twice about having jails if she was the victim of a physically abusive spouse. What if the speaker was raped, rape is not a crime to survive it’s a crime of lust. What about white collar crimes, Ponzi schemes, investment fruad, and so on. Oh, what if you were nearly beat to death by the KKK. Prisons are a necessity for a percentage of the population. It’s a wonderful thing to rehabilitate certain people, which the current prison system doesn’t do, but it’s still necessary. Just because there are people who are prisoners of their circumstances there are also prisoners who are beyond redemption. I don’t think a drug pin like El Chapo can ever become a functioning member of normal society.

    • I got angry in school all the time. I grew up getting made fun of. Never thought hey let’s bring an AR15 to school and shoot it up. Being a criminal is the easy way out. School too hard so I dropped out. I couldn’t get a job that would pay me enough to take care of kids, so I started selling drugs. It’s all just because it’s easier. And don’t say well I was pressured into selling drugs by my father. If I didn’t he would beat me. You had other options. If you wanted to do the right thing you could go to cops

    • Beatness What? So according to you NOBODY in prison is a terrible person? So people who do bad things are just good people deep down? The parkland shooter not a terrible person? Bernie Madoff a good guy just doing what he needed to do to survive? Cops who commit police brutality are just good guys trying to make it in the world? GTFO.

  2. Thank you for this message. The existence of prisons never made any sense to me and all of these ideas are so impactful and make sense to what is their purpose. Also the passion of the speaker is pulling.

    • Jade Eye If someone ever hurts you or your loved ones, you will be hoping they get prison. Life seems funny until it affects us…

    • Ahmed al-Dousari,

      a) to use the word “serve” is super confusing, because it does not actually “serves” anyone
      b) the whole idea of punishment is full of entitlement to strip away people’s freedom, whatever that entitlement is based on, it should not even be there in the first place, limiting anyone’s freedom is limiting freedom whatever way you look at it
      c) nobody is talking about money here, also if you are going to talk about money then you should incorporate two facts in you argument: time is money & employability is money; and both of these are taken away from people in a prison and released from a prison… actually you used the word ‘precious’ which signifies comparison of value, which is all that money represents, it is literally the agreed representation of value
      d) warning, deterrence, fear, theathening, whatever you want to call it are 1) less efficient than other types of motivational technigues which we know and the institutions talked about it the videos are trying to use 2) they are also directed towards society and not the offenders, which then makes no sense why they should be implimented upon them, if they are not directed towards them (and if you are going to mention re-offenders then I am going to mention that prisons are actually setting up people for greater reoffending rate, because of the way they are run and the conditions under which the prisoners are released back to their ‘normal’ lives that no longer exist; also partly because of the business that is running alongside the prison system which is another rant all together)
      e) you mention the willingness to commit a crime which makes me think that you are considering it to exist as an aspect to be considered, yet you are not considering it for what it is… if we are going to talk seriously about the willingness to commit a crime, then we are talking about those core issues that are behind such mindset, those core issues might be connected to the social, mental and physical state of the offender and their situation, and it is those core issues that these different types of justice system are adressing (and which prison is not adressing)

      I hope it is now clear why it is so hard to understand the purpose of prison, because there is all these factors that need to come in play when it comes to any kind of justification people come up with. But feel free to challenge my argument further.

    • Ahmed Al-Dousari
      “It also serves as a warning and a deterrence to others who are willing to commit a crime…”

      Which is why we no longer have crime.

      Nobody gets time back. It’s not a punishment.

    • Axiom Ape,
      please do not put me in a box, please do not try to predict my actions, please do not judge me until you at least try to get to know me. When we got that out of the way, we can get to you argument…
      When it comes to me personally: If someone ever hurts me or my loved one, I will not be hoping they get prison. If you want I will write that again… If someone ever hurts me or my loved one, I will not be hoping they get prison. Great. You want to know why? Because I do not wish ANYONE to be stripped away of their freedom and rights in the way prison does. Do you want to know what I would do instead? I would try to help the victim (if it would be me, I would seek help in other people and myself; if it would be my loved one, i would me there for them and focus the majority of my energy and attention on helping them get better in any way they find comfortable and effective). If it would come to doing anything about the offender, I would firstly want to have a constructive conversation with them, which would be hard, but that is the point of having it. I would then support any potential growth they want to achieve and accept any repent they want to offer. But I would not demand anything from them.
      When it comes to public interest: There is an obvious question of endangering any future potential victims (which is often used to justify incarseration) and this can be achieved in many different ways, but there are two main categories: 1) the public stops the potential of it happening, ex. death, incarseration, taking away financial, cultural, physical mobility, etc. 2) the public investigates the potential and adresses it, ex. constructive debate, solving core issues that led to commiting the crime, creating a more sustainable environment of the community which will secure the lives of the people within it, etc. It is really not that difficult to see why the second caregory of solutions is more effective, kinder, but also does not involve causing harm to others. I would also like to mention that for those victims and their loved ones who want to resolve any relationship with the offender, the prison justice system often makes it very difficult and thus can be harmful for their dealing with the situation as well.
      Thank you for reading my reply to you, please feel free to respond.

  3. I only made it about 3 minutes before I was pulling my hair out at the absurdity of her logic. I’ll be in my healing hut if anyone needs me.

    • Instead of kneejerking when someone says something perhaps listen to what they have to say and engage with it critically?

    • Adam Barron In Denmark the surviving father to a son lost in one of few mass shootings in a school, was sharing his view, a view in which He was acknowledging that the life of his son would not be restore by killing the attacker, or incarcerating him for life. He believes in a system in which the perpetrator of that horrible act of crime could be re-educated and enter society again. Why is so difficult for us to think that people cannot change? Why is easier to think in punishment before giving second chances?

  4. We wouldn’t need prisons if we killed the murderers, rapists, and pedophiles.
    For minor law breakers, theft, etc. this idea could work.

  5. https://youtu.be/gTY-zUtLMos
    This is how its here in Norway.
    Help instead off punish.
    This is new for usa, but elsewhere like in Norway this is old and constructive. It works !
    Police in Norway do not carry a weapon, and this works well.
    Everyone have done something bad in there life more or less, of many reasons.
    Just watch the video.

  6. i mean…. the n word is, just like you’d expect, a word…. do people *deserve* to get punched for saying that? i know that she was a kid and all of that but i’m talking in general… its just another way to verbally offend someone, if someone offends you verbally you definetly go on the wrong side as soon as you start moving a hand

  7. So call someone the N word and you deserve to be assaulted but if you are a cold blooded criminal you deserve to spend time in your happy love hut?

  8. Utter leftist garbage. Prison separates the bad from the good – and is supposed to be hard to remind them every minute of what they did. It’s not meant to be a leftist ideological holiday camp.

  9. The San Quentin prisoner designed a place that “was filled with these circular structures for victim and offender dialogue” yet he could not have that same dialogue with his victim because he killed them. This is a ridiculous talk. Obviously the prison system is in need of some reform but so too does the culture of the African- American and Hispanic populations that commit such crimes disproportionately.

    • Wiley Simonds Are you saying that blacks should take personal responsibility for their criminality instead of blaming “institutional racism” and white people?

    • “the culture of the African- American and Hispanic populations that commit such crimes disproportionately.” …Which is caused by things like institutional racism which can be seen in the disproportionate amount of minority prisoners.

    • Beatness I for one grew up to a single mother in a minority neighborhood. I was doomed to fail, drugs, gangs, violence and so on. I think you should hear out these other fellows. They want the same thing, a functioning minority population. Let’s be honest telling people to be personally responsibile for their actions is a good thing. I learned this message from a youth out reach program I was apart of for many years. In short, if you take responsibility, graduate high school, stay off drugs, don’t get involved in gangs, go to a cheap trade school, you won’t be poor. I did it, now my baby girl is going to Harvard. Anyone worth their salt can agree that minorities have not been treated well in America. Sympathy can sometimes hurt, it’s important to sometimes give someone a spine as opposed to coddle them. If I didn’t know that I’d be on the streets and on drugs. Which is why I think we need to teach all children of all colors to work hard and be responsible. It’s the first non controversial step we can take as a nation. Regardless of whether institutional racism is just a meaningless buzzword to me, while you believe it to be tangible, this whole responsibility thing is a way for you to fight back without any laws. If you look at the Black Pathers, some of the non violent chapters did exactly this, that’s what we can all agree on. That’s what some folks think when they say institutional racism isn’t a problem.

    • RigaDoomer Thanks for such a thoughtful answer! While I completely agree with what you’re saying, I still think there is a larger issue. Of course personal responsibility and hard work are important, but for some people that isn’t enough. I’m glad that it was for you, but that doesn’t mean that things like institutional racism aren’t still a problem for a large population.

  10. I don’t typically do this (leave a comment and dislike) but this video is so naive. Please everybody, we need to socially shame this video. Leave a negative comment and dislike. Thank you.

  11. Im black and I felt the comment about hitting the kid because he called her the N word was off base and not neccessary to convey this point, and then to say he deserved it completely made me discredit the rest of your talk, which by the way is leftist fantasyland. My sister you can do better and TED PLEASE find better speakers. I may have to unsubscribe it keeps getting worse.

    • That, on top of the other leftist fantasy of using violence to your own whim and imagining that it wont turn back around at you or others someday.

    • They will learn soon enough, im in Europe currently and Its clear what left policies have done here, boy are they starting to regret. Sweden will be a 3rd world country in the next 5 years, quite a shame.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


Shares
Share This